Philadelphia will become the first major U.S. city to ban police from making traffic stops for minor violations such as broken tail lights when Mayor Jim Kenney signs City Council-approved legislation as soon as this week.
Such stops have been encouraged in some police departments as a pretext to search vehicles of drivers suspected of carrying illegal drugs or weapons. But critics of the stops say they prompt a disproportionate number of stops involving drivers of color.
“#DrivingEquality reinforces that public safety can be achieved with other methods than traffic stops,” Councilmember Isaiah Thomas, the bill’s author, tweeted Sunday. “Traffic stops are traumatic for drivers and scary for police officers. Limiting them makes everyone safer and communities stronger.”
The issue resurfaced in Brooklyn Center, Minnesota, in April when Daunte Wright, a 20-year-old Black man, was fatally shot during a stop initiated for an air freshener hanging from his rearview mirror and expired car registration tags. Officers later attempted to arrest Wright for an outstanding warrant and, after a brief struggle, Wright was shot at close range.
A goal of the Driving Equality Bill is to ease tension between police and community members by removing negative interaction through minor traffic stops. The law divides motor vehicle code violations into “primary violations” that will continue to draw traffic stops in the interest of public safety and “secondary violations” that won’t.
What Black drivers face: Police officers speak to Black drivers less respectfully, study finds. Here’s why it matters
“These bills end the traffic stops that promote discrimination while keeping the traffic stops that promote public safety,” City Council said in a statement.
The plan also allows police to redirect time and resources toward safety while removing “negative interactions that widen the divide and perpetuate mistrust,” the statement said.
Thomas, who is Black, said his office was flooded with calls from people complaining of humiliation and trauma at traffic stops. Thomas said the legislation will make the city’s streets safer and more equitable.
“To many people who look like me, a traffic stop is a rite of passage,” Thomas said. “We pick out cars, we determine routes, we plan our social interactions around the fact that it is likely that we will be pulled over by police.”
Thomas said he wants his sons and other Black children to grow up in a city where being pulled over is not a rite of passage but a measure driving safety “regardless of the skin color of the driver.”
The bill allows the Philadelphia Police Department 120 days for training and education before being implemented. It won overwhelming approval from the City Council with a 14-2 vote. A companion bill, approved by a 15-1 vote, mandates a public, searchable database of traffic stops that includes driver and officer information, reason for conducting traffic stop as well as demographic and geographic information.
Data was a main component in illustrating the problem and will be a major factor in analyzing the success or need for alterations to the bill, Thomas said.
“Data and lived experiences showed us the problem and data will be key to making sure this is done right,” Thomas said. “Data will tell us if we should end more traffic stops or amend how this is enforced. Data will also tell other cities that Philadelphia is leading on this civil rights issue and it can be replicated.”